Request

Hey Sam! 

As someone who games on both PC and PlayStation, I'd recommend looking at this from a "best overall experience" perspective rather than just picking the most popular controller.

Since you mainly play on PC but also own a PS5, here are the two I'd personally consider:

Option 1: Sony DualSense Wireless Controller (My Pick)

Price: $84.00

If you already own a PS5, this is honestly the best all-round choice. It works great on PC via Steam (wired or Bluetooth) while giving you the full PS5 experience with adaptive triggers and haptic feedback in supported games. It also feels incredibly comfortable for long gaming sessions and has one of the best ergonomics of any modern controller. 

Why I'd choose it:

✅ One controller for both PC and PS5.

✅ Excellent ergonomics for long sessions.

✅ Premium haptic feedback & adaptive triggers.

✅ USB-C + Bluetooth support.

✅ Fits comfortably within your $100 budget.

Option 2: 8BitDo Ultimate 2 Wireless Controller

Price: Around $60 to $70 

If PC is where you spend 90% of your gaming time, I'd seriously look at the 8BitDo Ultimate 2. It comes with TMR/Hall-effect technology for better durability, a charging dock, excellent battery life, and fantastic customization software. It's one of the best value-for-money PC controllers available today.

Why it's worth considering:

✅ TMR/Hall-effect sticks help reduce stick drift.

✅ Charging dock included.

✅ Great battery life.

✅ Excellent for Steam, Epic Games, Xbox Game Pass and emulators.

My Take

If I could only buy one, I'd go with the Sony DualSense. Since you already own a PS5, it gives you the best of both worlds without compromising on either platform. Unless you're chasing competitive PC-only features like Hall-effect sticks, I don't think you'll regret the DualSense—it just feels right in the hands.

Happy gaming! 🎮

For a reliable everyday game controller that seamlessly works across both your PC and your PS5 under a $100 budget on Newegg, the standard options are surprisingly specific. Due to Sony’s strict security protocols on the PlayStation 5, generic multi-platform controllers often do not work with native PS5 games.

To bridge this gap effectively while keeping things simple and within your budget, here are the top choices available on Newegg:

The Best Native Choice

If you want guaranteed, zero-hassle compatibility out of the box for every single game on both platforms, the official controller is your best bet.

Sony DualSense Wireless Controller

₹6,390.00·Sony

4.7(102.1k+)

The Sony DualSense Wireless Controller is the standard controller for the PS5, retailing well under your budget at around $70 to $75. It works perfectly on PC through a simple USB-C or Bluetooth connection.

• Why it fits: On the PC side, Steam has native integration for the DualSense. Many modern PC ports even support its premium haptic feedback and adaptive triggers when plugged in via USB. You get standard console-grade durability without paying a premium for unnecessary "pro" features.

The Multi-Platform Workaround Choice

If you prefer an Xbox-style layout (asymmetrical thumbsticks) for your PC gaming but still want to use that exact same controller on your PS5, a dedicated converter is the most reliable strategy under $100.

Brook Gaming Wingman P5 Converter

The Brook Gaming Wingman P5 Converter sits right around $70 on Newegg. This is a premium USB dongle that plugs directly into your PS5 or PC.

• Why it fits: It allows you to cross-pair almost any major wireless controller you might already own (like an Xbox controller, Switch Pro controller, or older pads) to work seamlessly with native PS5 games and your PC. It supports vibration and motion control mapping via its software, making it a highly reliable way to use a single everyday layout across both systems.

This is perfect for a controller that looks good and especially if you're a fan of first light :)

Current price is around $74.99. It gives you the full PS5 experience: haptic feedback, adaptive triggers, excellent ergonomics, built-in microphone, and wireless connectivity. If you want to stay under $100, I would buy the official DualSense rather than a third-party PS5 controller.